Korean pop culture, in numbers

Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker

Four Southeast Asian Wikipedias, four different Korean athletes at the top. The question is not who is biggest but why the four lists disagree.

The most-read Korean athlete, taken one edition at a time, is Son Heung-min, Faker, Son Heung-min, Bergson Gustavo Silveira da Silva — 3 different people across four countries. The four editions do not agree, and this page is about why.

Of the 950 people measured, 900 are recorded only as players and 49 as both player and manager. Those 49 are kept in a separate table below rather than ranked against current players.

The four editions, side by side

Reads per million reads of the whole language edition, 12 months. One row is one person. Dividing by the size of each edition is what makes the four comparable — the Indonesian Wikipedia draws several times the reads the Malay one does, so raw counts would only measure the encyclopaedias, not the readers.

Indonesia

Indonesian Wikipedia · 838M reads in the window · 360 Korean athletes have an article here

AthletePer millionSport
Son Heung-min80.98Football
Park Ji-Sung20.82Football
Lee Kang-in12.37Football
Kim Min-jae7.89Football
Jens Castrop6.84Football
Ahn Jung-hwan5.98Football
Yoo Jae-hoon5.44Football
Hwang Hee-chan4.23Football

Football 98.7% · Baseball 1% · Esports 0.2% ·

Vietnam

Vietnamese Wikipedia · 595M reads in the window · 663 Korean athletes have an article here

AthletePer millionSport
Faker250.45Esports
Son Heung-min144.63Football
Peanut96.19Esports
Lee Min-hyung88.57Esports
Jung Ji-hun78.48Esports
Kim Soo-hwan72.5Esports
Ryu Min-seok68.31Esports
Doran59.48Esports

Esports 59.4% · Football 40.3% · Baseball 0.2% ·

Thailand

Thai Wikipedia · 369M reads in the window · 67 Korean athletes have an article here

AthletePer millionSport
Son Heung-min104.99Football
Park Ji-Sung17.9Football
Kim Min-jae10.15Football
Faker9.66Esports
Go Seul-ki5.21Football
Hwang Hee-chan4.91Football
Lee Kang-in4.78Football
Cho Gue-sung3.15Football

Football 93.4% · Esports 4.8% · Golf 1.2% ·

Malaysia

Malay Wikipedia · 163M reads in the window · 370 Korean athletes have an article here

AthletePer millionSport
Bergson Gustavo Silveira da Silva32.46Football
Son Heung-min11.7Football
Park Ji-Sung6.16Football
Park Tae-soo5.9Football
Faker3.63Esports
Park Jun-heong2.83Football
Lee Kang-in2.62Football
Kim Young-kwang2.04Football

Football 89.4% · Baseball 8.5% · Esports 2.2% ·

Korean footballers, all four countries at once

One row per person, all four editions on the row. Reads per million first, then the raw count of times the article was opened, so the scaling can be checked against the thing it scales. Concentration is the share of that person's four-country total that sits in their largest single country — a player read everywhere lands near 25%, a player read in one place lands near 100%.

PlayerIndonesiaVietnamThailandMalaysiaTotalConcentration
Son Heung-min80.98 (67,903)144.63 (86,094)104.99 (38,704)11.7 (1,907)342.342.3% vi
Park Ji-Sung20.82 (17,453)29.56 (17,598)17.9 (6,599)6.16 (1,004)74.4439.7% vi
Lee Kang-in12.37 (10,372)28.34 (16,872)4.78 (1,762)2.62 (427)48.1158.9% vi
Kim Min-jae7.89 (6,613)19.36 (11,525)10.15 (3,740)1.29 (210)38.6950% vi
Bergson Gustavo Silveira da Silva—0.5 (298)—32.46 (5,289)32.9698.5% ms
Hwang Hee-chan4.23 (3,549)8.53 (5,078)4.91 (1,810)—17.6748.3% vi
Jens Castrop6.84 (5,737)5.26 (3,131)—0.92 (150)13.0252.5% id
Ahn Jung-hwan5.98 (5,014)5.28 (3,142)—0.93 (152)12.1949.1% id
Hwang Ui-jo0.65 (549)9.11 (5,422)0.58 (215)0.93 (151)11.2780.8% vi
Cho Gue-sung2.15 (1,802)5.38 (3,202)3.15 (1,160)—10.6850.4% vi
Ki Sung-yueng1.17 (982)4 (2,381)1.72 (634)1.03 (168)7.9250.5% vi
Gong O-kyun—6.96 (4,144)——6.96100% vi
Hwang In-beom2.32 (1,946)4.46 (2,656)0.17 (62)—6.9564.2% vi
Lee Seung-woo1.34 (1,123)3.37 (2,008)—1.95 (318)6.6650.6% vi

The Koreans who played, then managed

Wikidata records both roles for anyone who played before managing, so it cannot say which one a reader came for. We keep them in their own table rather than rank a national-team manager against a player. In two of these four countries the most-read Korean is a manager, and that is the finding, not a nuisance.

ManagerIndonesiaVietnamThailandMalaysiaTotalConcentration
Kim Sang-sik1.84 (1,542)132.71 (79,001)2.57 (947)0.66 (107)137.7896.3% vi
Shin Tae-yong74.72 (62,647)9.58 (5,700)2.7 (995)6.05 (986)93.0580.3% id
Park Hang-seo3.22 (2,704)60.77 (36,177)7.31 (2,696)2.44 (397)73.7482.4% vi
Cha Bum-kun—27.42 (16,320)—2.26 (369)29.6892.4% vi
Hong Myung-bo7.52 (6,306)14.19 (8,450)4.32 (1,593)1.54 (251)27.5751.5% vi
Kim Pan-gon———10.08 (1,642)10.08100% ms
Lee Jung-soo0.23 (197)5.54 (3,296)0.46 (168)0.2 (32)6.4386.2% vi
Kim Do-hoon0.93 (781)1.59 (946)—0.2 (33)2.7258.5% vi
Hwang Sun-hong0.65 (545)1.6 (950)—0.29 (48)2.5463% vi
Lee Young-jin—1.7 (1,011)——1.7100% vi
Huh Jung-moo0.54 (453)0.97 (578)——1.5164.2% vi
Kim Do-heon—1.04 (618)—0.29 (48)1.3378.2% vi

Median concentration is 50.55% for the players and 81.35% for the managers. A player's readership is spread across the region; a manager's sits in the country that hired him.

The top manager scores 137.78 against the top player's 342.3. Of the 14 players listed above, 13 score below that one manager — who earns it in a single country while they are spread over four.

The most-read Korean manager scores 137.78 against the most-read player's 342.3. Of the 14 players listed, 13 score below the top manager. A manager is read in one country and a player in several, which is why the two are in separate tables and not one ranking.

What a read is not

Reading an encyclopaedia article is not the same as following a sport. This counts people looking someone up. It cannot say who is liked, only who is looked up.

Readers in Southeast Asia also use the English edition, so a language-edition count is a floor on interest in that country, not a measure of it.

Of 8,917 Korean athletes on Wikidata, 7,967 have no article in any of these four editions. That is an absence of an article, not an absence of interest, and we do not count it as a zero.

The country we did not measure

Tagalog Wikipedia is too small to measure with — the whole edition draws fewer reads in a year than a single popular article does elsewhere, and Filipino readers largely use the English edition. We do not report a Philippines number rather than report a weak one.

How this was counted

How esports titles travel · How we count · What we have corrected

Card set — free to share

Five cards, 1080×1350. Every figure on them is in the table on this page. Take them.

Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker — card 1 of 5Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker — card 2 of 5Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker — card 3 of 5Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker — card 4 of 5Indonesia and Thailand look up Son Heung-min. Vietnam looks up Faker — card 5 of 5

A short, with sound

A man and a woman read out the two medians — how much of a player's reading sits in one country, and how much of a manager's does — and name the countries that hired them. Free to repost with the address on it.

All our short films — each one built from a table on this site

What we wrote from this data

What happens if we remove one person

GroupPeopleMedianLowest without oneHighest without oneSwing
Players1450.5%50.5%50.6%0.1 pt
Managers1281.3%80.3%82.4%2.1 pt

Removing any single person moves the players' median by 0.1 points and the managers' by 2.1. The gap between the two groups, which is the finding, survives both.

This check is a jackknife, and a jackknife understates how much a median moves — it is not consistent for a median at all. So a swing it finds is real, but a swing it does not find is not evidence of stability. We publish it as the weaker statement it is.